This all started when researching whether a 95W processor would be a problem on a motherboard that had a recommendation of 65W.
The jury seems to be out on that one - but it does highlight a number of points.
The TDP is a "nominal" or a maximum value for the specified processor (it is likely that your processor will consume less power and processors can be selected from production runs for units that exhibit low power consumption)
These processors can be sold at a premium or they can get re-branded as low TDP devices. Due to the nature of how Intel and AMD market their products it is not clear how this manifests itself. Those at review sites, such as Anandtech, can speculate on this - but it will probably remain unknown to the exact state of affairs.
In any case, it is probably true that processors that have a lower TDP are not necessarily better capable to be overclocked. This seems to be the #1 concern of the "fanboys" on review sites.
NemesisChild On an AMD forum says: "Do your research!"
On the Zotac website: "GF8200-C-E with Phenom X3 8750 (95w TDP) 65w motherboard with 95w CPU" - this is the board I want to use a 95W, a poster comments:
"on here one person responds with a list of approved processors that says you can't use anything higher than 65w, but then it looks like a Zotac moderator says you can:"
The "Moderator" says:
"Any processor compatible with any AM2+ board should run fine. A BIOS update may be needed to recognize the name of processors released after the most most recent BIOS."
I am not sure that it does - I don't know that Infested Nexus is a Zotac Moderator (Update: Looking deaper on the Zotac website - Infested Nexus seems to be the main contributor - However, his profile says nothing of him (or her) being the moderator - I recieved my Zotac GF8200-C-E Motherboard - a quick look at the documentation - Zotac are not Asus! There will be a review of the ITX project posted later (see link below).
The links to these quotes were on my website, they will be republished on this blog.
My intention is to use an AMD 550 (95W) on the Zotac itx board - I purchased the m/b with a 190W AMD Phenom II X4 965 (which is going to be used in my "7 Box") - this would be "pushing it"
The jury seems to be out on that one - but it does highlight a number of points.
The TDP is a "nominal" or a maximum value for the specified processor (it is likely that your processor will consume less power and processors can be selected from production runs for units that exhibit low power consumption)
These processors can be sold at a premium or they can get re-branded as low TDP devices. Due to the nature of how Intel and AMD market their products it is not clear how this manifests itself. Those at review sites, such as Anandtech, can speculate on this - but it will probably remain unknown to the exact state of affairs.
In any case, it is probably true that processors that have a lower TDP are not necessarily better capable to be overclocked. This seems to be the #1 concern of the "fanboys" on review sites.
NemesisChild On an AMD forum says: "Do your research!"
On the Zotac website: "GF8200-C-E with Phenom X3 8750 (95w TDP) 65w motherboard with 95w CPU" - this is the board I want to use a 95W, a poster comments:
"on here one person responds with a list of approved processors that says you can't use anything higher than 65w, but then it looks like a Zotac moderator says you can:"
The "Moderator" says:
"Any processor compatible with any AM2+ board should run fine. A BIOS update may be needed to recognize the name of processors released after the most most recent BIOS."
I am not sure that it does - I don't know that Infested Nexus is a Zotac Moderator (Update: Looking deaper on the Zotac website - Infested Nexus seems to be the main contributor - However, his profile says nothing of him (or her) being the moderator - I recieved my Zotac GF8200-C-E Motherboard - a quick look at the documentation - Zotac are not Asus! There will be a review of the ITX project posted later (see link below).
The links to these quotes were on my website, they will be republished on this blog.
My intention is to use an AMD 550 (95W) on the Zotac itx board - I purchased the m/b with a 190W AMD Phenom II X4 965 (which is going to be used in my "7 Box") - this would be "pushing it"